FloridaHOA Court Cases & Lawsuits (2026)
Florida's dense condo and HOA landscape has generated landmark litigation on association authority, assessment enforcement, and homeowner free speech rights — with courts generally upholding association power while demanding procedural regularity.
3
of 7 cases
3
of 7 cases
1
of 7 cases
Landmark Cases — Florida
Woodside Village Condo. Assn. v. Jahren
Short-term rental ban upheld
The association amended its declaration to prohibit rentals of less than one year after the original documents allowed flexible leasing. Current owners challenged the amendment as an invalid restriction on their property rights. The Florida Supreme Court held that owners who purchase in a condominium association are on notice that the declaration may be amended through the proper process, and rental restrictions amended after purchase are valid and enforceable.
Properly enacted amendments to HOA declarations restricting short-term rentals are enforceable against all current owners regardless of purchase date.
What this means
For Homeowners
Buying into an HOA means accepting that the rules may change through the amendment process. A rental restriction adopted after your purchase is generally valid if it follows the amendment procedures in your declaration.
For Boards
Rental restriction amendments must strictly follow the amendment procedures in the declaration. Document member approval, notice, and voting records. An amendment that follows proper procedure will withstand challenge even from owners who relied on prior rental flexibility.
Concerned Neighbors of Boca Ciega Bay v. Pinellas County
Deed restriction and municipal authority intersect
Homeowners challenged a county-approved development project that conflicted with deed restrictions in their subdivision documents. The court found that while deed restrictions can be enforced against private parties, municipal authorities are not bound by private deed restrictions when acting within their governmental powers. The case was ultimately resolved through settlement requiring environmental mitigation.
Private deed restrictions are enforceable against private parties but do not bind governmental entities acting within their authorized powers.
What this means
For Homeowners
HOA deed restrictions only bind private parties. If a government agency approves a project in or adjacent to your community, the HOA's restrictions may not stop governmental action, though environmental and zoning laws may provide separate remedies.
For Boards
Deed restrictions are private contracts between owners and cannot compel government compliance. If a public project threatens your community, consult environmental and land use attorneys about statutory remedies beyond HOA enforcement.
Chattel Mortgage Corp. v. Belleair Manor Condominium Assn.
Assessment lien priority upheld
A first mortgage lender challenged the association's right to collect past-due assessments from the proceeds of a foreclosure sale, arguing that the mortgage should have priority. The court upheld Florida statute giving condominium association assessment liens limited priority over first mortgages for up to one year of assessments, recognizing the unique financial interdependence of condominium communities.
Florida law grants condominium associations limited lien priority for up to one year of unpaid assessments over first mortgage liens.
What this means
For Homeowners
If you fall behind on assessments, the association may foreclose its lien even if you are current on your mortgage. Florida law gives associations priority for up to one year of unpaid assessments in a mortgage foreclosure scenario.
For Boards
Florida's assessment lien statute is a powerful collection tool. File your lien promptly, pursue collection consistently, and work with HOA counsel to navigate the lien priority rules when first mortgages are involved in foreclosure proceedings.
Pudlit 2 Joint Venture LLP v. Westwood Gardens HOA
Improperly noticed special assessment invalidated
The association levied a significant special assessment for capital improvements without providing the legally required notice period to members before the vote. The court found that the lack of proper advance notice rendered the special assessment procedurally invalid, even though the underlying capital project was legitimate.
Florida HOA special assessments are void if levied without the statutory advance notice required for the member meeting at which they are approved.
What this means
For Homeowners
Special assessments must follow strict notice procedures under Florida law. If your association levied a major special assessment without proper advance written notice to all members, you may have grounds to challenge the assessment's validity.
For Boards
Special assessment procedures under Florida law are not optional. Provide written notice of the meeting where the assessment will be voted on, comply with all statutory timing requirements, and document your compliance carefully. A procedural defect can invalidate an entire assessment even if the project itself was reasonable.
Sproul v. Mullarkey
HOA ordered to produce financial records
A homeowner requested financial records from the association, which the board refused to produce citing privacy concerns and ongoing disputes with the requestor. The court held that Florida's HOA statute grants members a clear right to inspect official records within a set timeframe, and the association's refusal justified a court order compelling production and awarding attorney fees.
Florida HOA members have a statutory right to inspect official association records; refusal to comply within the statutory period results in penalties and mandatory attorney fees.
What this means
For Homeowners
Florida law gives HOA members an affirmative right to inspect official records including financial statements, contracts, and meeting minutes. If your association refuses a valid records request within the statutory period, you can seek a court order and attorney fees.
For Boards
Official records requests must be fulfilled within 10 business days under Florida statute (§720.303). Refusing a valid request or imposing unreasonable conditions can result in a court order, $50 per day penalties, and attorney fee liability.
Bastian v. Sunset Bay Club Condo. Assn.
Exterior modification removal ordered
A unit owner installed hurricane shutters that did not conform to the association's approved specifications and failed to obtain architectural approval before installation. The court upheld the association's right to require removal and awarded the association attorney fees under the statute permitting fees to the prevailing party in HOA enforcement actions.
Exterior modifications without association approval must be removed at the owner's expense; Florida law provides attorney fee recovery to the prevailing party in HOA enforcement actions.
What this means
For Homeowners
Always obtain written architectural approval before making exterior modifications. Installing approved products in unapproved colors, materials, or configurations is treated the same as installing unapproved items — and the association can require costly removal and sue for attorney fees.
For Boards
Enforce architectural standards consistently. Florida's prevailing-party attorney fee provision in HOA disputes is a significant deterrent against unauthorized modifications when boards enforce their standards uniformly.
Coronado Condo. Assn. v. La Corte
Service animal accommodation required
A resident with a documented disability requested permission to keep a service animal despite a no-pets policy in the condominium rules. The association denied the request citing the blanket pet prohibition. The court held that a no-pets rule must yield to a reasonable accommodation request for a service or assistance animal under the Fair Housing Act and Florida fair housing law.
HOA no-pets policies must yield to Fair Housing Act accommodation requests for service and assistance animals from residents with documented disabilities.
What this means
For Homeowners
A no-pets HOA rule cannot be applied to deny a reasonable accommodation for a verified service animal or emotional support animal. Submit your request in writing with documentation from a healthcare provider.
For Boards
A no-pets rule is not a defense to a Fair Housing accommodation request for an assistance animal. Evaluate each request individually, engage in an interactive process, and grant the accommodation unless you can demonstrate undue hardship — a very high bar that aesthetic preferences do not meet.
Self-manage your Florida HOA and reduce dispute risk — try LotWize.
The cases above show how procedural mistakes, inconsistent enforcement, and poor record-keeping lead to costly litigation. LotWize helps self-managed boards in Florida track violations consistently, document meeting minutes properly, and follow the procedures that protect the association from the lawsuits in this database.
Start 14-Day Free TrialNot legal advice. Educational purposes only. Case summaries are simplified for general audiences and may omit procedural history, subsequent developments, or nuances relevant to specific situations. Florida HOA law varies by community type, governing documents, and changes in statute. Always consult a licensed Florida HOA attorney for advice specific to your situation. Last reviewed: 2026.